Co-op/Internship Experience vs. GPA……Which Wins?

By Stephen Patchin posted 04-10-2018 08:13

  

Company conversion rate co-op/intern to full-time employee: 61 percent
 (median – 80 percent )


A recent survey of career services directors at STEM-focused universities found that more than 85 percent were experiencing increased interest from students in participating in co-ops or internships during their collegiate experience.

In STEM areas of study these internships/co-ops are paid jobs with very few exceptions. Kelly Laraway of North Carolina State University notes “We also only allow paid internships in the for-profit sector to be listed in our career management system.” At Michigan Tech, interns/co-op garner average salaries of $20 per hour.

Collecting information on co-ops and internships that are associated with an on-campus course is the most common way of collecting data. Tracking internships not associated with a class, often summer jobs related to their degrees, is much more challenging. Tufts University students self-report to an internship profile book, while Deborah Liverman at MIT notes their students complete outcomes surveys and summer experience surveys to gather the information.

Will your company be increasing the number of internships it offers?
77 percent – YES!

In the search for a strong college full-time hire, employers are reviewing and redefining characteristics on what makes an engineering candidate stand out. Is it the student’s performance in academics, which might translate to the understanding of basic engineering fundamentals? Or, is it the practical hands-on experience obtained through internships and co-ops, which showcases real-world complex problem-solving abilities, interpersonal, and communication skills? 

With companies increasing the number of internship/co-op positions each year, the more vital considerations are: 1) Which of these might give the STEM student the advantage in his or her job search, and 2) Which of these might benefit the company in the long-term strategy? 

What does co-op/internship experience mean to companies?

 

  • Charlie Kramer from Meyer Contracting, “Understanding our culture, our work ethic expectations, our demands of our employees, and corresponding rewards.”
  • Josh Szymanski from Owen Ames Kimball, “Students learn to work with others through problems, politics, and conflict on projects. They also see real world application on concepts they are learning during the school year.”
  • Angela Stemo from HUSCO, “Students also gain confidence in themselves and their engineering knowledge through executive presentation.”
  • Scott Liebelt from BCI Burke Company, LLC., “Another advantage to co-op/internship experience is what it can do for you during the interview process. It opens up a lot more situations and experiences that you can draw from when answering questions.”
  • Matt Rosentreter with Burns & McDonnell, “Internships provide industry-specific experience and exposure, which provides students with valuable insight into future opportunities, as well as, gives them an edge as they come into the work force after graduation.”

What do students see as their value?

  • “The level of project autonomy I have and the incredible learning experiences are the most satisfying while on co-op.” – Ryan, Michigan Tech co-op, Bemis
  • “The greatest value a co-op brings to a company is their point of view and the way they look at the world. They are new to the company and are not yet accustomed to the way things have been, which is why they are more open to ideas of change and trying new ideas which might help. Another value that co-op students bring to a company is to show the type of work ethic and knowledge that comes from being at a specific college to aid the co-op hiring process in the future.” Jenna, Michigan Tech co-op, Greenheck
  • “Stepping into a refinery was like stepping into a textbook. Heat transfer, mass balances, and reaction kinetics surrounded me daily.” – Demetrius, Michigan Tech co-op, Marathon Petroleum Company
What do recruiters value most?
Co-op/Internship Experience – 51 percent | GPA – 13 percent | Both – 36 percent

When asked if internships/co-op were valuable, a respondent from Twitter stated, “Yes, I believe so. Although I believe college is a test of how well an individual can approach, learn from, and retain new information, I do believe real work experience is more valuable. The ability to navigate through an organization or even understand what navigating through an organization means, is key in quick success at any company.” 

Although employers recognized that some companies in the selection criteria might require a minimum GPA, many more stated that once this was met, experience would take precedence in their choice, especially with upperclassmen seeking full-time jobs.  

For example, a student who has a 3.0 GPA with experience would more often than not be chosen over a student with a 4.0 and no experience. A respondent from Caterpillar said, “Both are very valuable to have, but students considered for Caterpillar internships must meet the minimum GPA specified on the job opening in order to be considered. However, involvement in extracurricular activities and other work experiences, even if it is not related to their major, is more important than the higher GPA. We are looking for well-rounded students that have demonstrated the ability to balance their time. The experience gained working, while applying what they have learned in class, demonstrates they have the ability to do that and work with others in a full-time position. For these reasons, we seek out individuals that have had co-op, internship, and/or extracurricular experiences on their resumes.” 

As with Caterpillar, many of the employer comments centered on the preference for a well-rounded candidate, especially with full-time candidates, emphasizing that GPA is important, but experience shows application of the skills they have learned. 

Respondents said that GPA alone does not indicate application of skills such as communication or the ability to learn from mistakes. With so much of the coursework for students being similar, what makes the individual stand out is the work they have done outside the classroom. 

One responded said, “Although grades are important, hands-on experience is priceless. When you go out to the work force and you can point to actual projects and examples of your work, it will go a long way to set you apart from other applicants.” 

This sentiment was echoed by a spokesperson at ARCO, “We feel co-op experience, coupled with a strong GPA, is the largest recipe for success at ARCO. We seek the brightest and the best, both in terms of experience and overall academics.” 

Will you make room for top talent?
88 percent - YES!

We then asked company recruiters “If you find strong candidates on the recruiting trail, will you make a position for them?” Eighty-eight percent responded with a resounding YES! Corporate America manages budgets to maximize profits and drive share price. Its most precious and scarce commodity is the graduates our STEM-focused institutions are producing, so much so that they will make space for them on their teams, regardless of budget. That is the definition of a valued asset!

Note: A session at the NACE 2018 Conference & Expo, Trends and Opportunities in Recruiting STEM Students, will be held on Thursday, June 7, 1:30 - 2:30 p.m. It will feature a panel of career services leaders at STEM-focused institutions.

Authors:

Steve Patchin – Michigan Technological University

Julie Pittsner – Missouri S & T

Jean Manning-Clark – Colorado School of Mines

Sarah Raymond – Montana Tech

Permalink

Comments

04-10-2018 13:55

Great, and important, post.  Also a big difference between which should win versus which does.
The issue is that with so many applicants for any job, employers often rely on automated tools to filter out based upon GPA so that the amazing student with incredible intern / co-op experience does not even make it into the pool. And that's before even considering the other issues that impact GPA...